9 Website Strategies (Besides Testimonials) for Proving Your Way to More Sales

by Adam Kreitman

Last updated on March 5th, 2018

“Why should I believe you?”

There are a lot of questions going through a prospect’s mind when they come to your website. And this is one of the biggies you have to answer (and answer well!) because your prospects are…

  • Numb from being slammed by hundreds of marketing messages each day.
  • Pissed off because they’ve bought plenty of products/services before that have failed to live up to their lofty claims.
  • Confused and frustrated because, with so many choices, it’s difficult to differentiate one competitor’s solution from the next.

A few months ago I wrote an article here about the 4 website elements I’d take over good design any day. One of these is what I call “The Credibility Factor”. Basically it’s about how to prove you’re someone your prospects should do business with.

Featuring elements of credibility and proof on your website is critical to conversions.…especially in this day and age where skepticism of advertising claims is sky high.

The most common way to bolster your credibility is the testimonial. But there are plenty of other ways to prove you’re worthy of a prospect’s dinero.

So let’s look at 9 other ways you can beef up “The Credibility Factor” on your website to help convert skeptical prospects into buyers.


Reviews are similar to testimonials. But they’re more powerful because they come from the actual users of a product/service sharing their impressions directly on your site.

While reviews work especially well for eCommerce sites selling products (Amazon.com being the most noteworthy example), it can also work in other niches.

One example is SitterCity, a site where you can find local nannies and babysitters. As you can see in the screenshot below, they allow users to leave ratings for the sitters listed on their site.

Reviews As Social Proof

It’s one thing for the sitters to post on their profile about how wonderful they are, but something quite different for parents who have hired them to write a review saying how the sitter was on time, how much their kids loved the sitter, how the sitter stayed calm during a 45 minute temper tantrum by a 2 year old, etc.

Related Recognition/Credentials

Won any awards? Received any special recognition for your work? Were you trained by one of the top gurus in your field?

If so, let your prospects know about it!

Last year my company was voted one of the Best Marketing Firms in St. Louis. As soon as that came out you better believe I put that above the fold on my website!

Not only that, but I added “Award Winning” in the title tag of my home page so people are sure to see that in the search engines. Soon after doing this I picked up a new client who specifically mentioned that award as a main reason for contacting me.

But it doesn’t have to be an award. It can be your educational background, industry certifications, special training, membership in industry organizations (especially if you’ve had a leadership role), etc.

The key is that it’s related to your business.

The fact that you won first prize in the local hot dog eating contest will probably not help the credibility of your wedding photography business!


Media attention means credibility in the minds of most consumers. It doesn’t matter whether it’s from TV, radio, newspapers, magazines or an online media source.

The fact that you, your company, or your products/services are noteworthy enough to get attention from the media provides that Credibility Factor we’re looking for.

One way to highlight this coverage is to have a page on your site that features videos, press releases, stories, etc. from media exposure.

Adding the logos of the media outlets you’ve been featured on is another great way to highlight your media coverage. Just use a header like “As Seen On” or “Featured On” above the logos.

Last month I used an ad from a plastic surgeon in Beverly Hills in the examples of successful AdWords ads. Here’s a screen capture of the section of his website of the media outlets he’s been featured on. This certainly makes an impression on prospective patients in this market!

Cite Studies/Research

Citing studies (preferably from well known research universities, organizations or institutes) is another way to add some proof to your claims.

The weight loss and diet supplement markets are great examples of industries that frequently cite scientific studies to bolster their claims. Here’s an example from a company in the supplement market that states right in the banner at the top of their site “Doctor designed, research supported™ Formulated by physicians from Harvard, Cornell, MIT and Bastyr”.

They back this up elsewhere on their site and provide a link to see the research data supporting their products.

If you can cite research or studies done on your product (or at least on the core concepts your product is based on), share that with your prospects! The research will help prove your case better than you trying to make the case on your own.

Feature Notable Clients

We don’t have to look any further than the Crazy Egg site to find a good example of a company featuring high profile clients that are using their product/service.

Having companies like Disney, Sony and Toyota on your client list is a big deal. The credibility it provides is huge. It’s an instant validation in a prospect’s mind that your product/service is the real deal.


Most people talk about guarantees as a way of reducing a prospect’s risk of buying from you. And, no doubt, it’s certainly a great way to do that.

But a strong guarantee also shows that you stand behind your product/service (while reducing the risk to the prospect). And the stronger the guarantee, the more credibility it provides.

Here’s a great example from a dentist’s office in the Washington D.C. area. They have a page on their site specifically laying out the 3 guarantees they offer patients at their practice…

Sure they could say patients have a comfortable experience at their office, can expect a short wait and the office does a great job on crowns, veneers and onlays. But a guarantee puts some teeth into those claims and adds a level of credibility their competitors don’t have.

A powerful guarantee can be an especially useful form of credibility for a new company/product/service. If you don’t have testimonials, reviews, noteworthy clients, etc., offering a strong guarantee to show you fully believe and stand behind your offer may the best option you have.

Professional Design

What can I add here?! If you’re reading this blog, you’re very well aware of the credibility that a well designed website carries!

Be Specific

I wrote about the importance of specificity last month in regards to AdWords ads. Whether it’s in AdWords ads or on your website (or any form of marketing, for that matter), you add credibility to the mix by being specific.

In fact, many of the other Credibility Factors mentioned in this post can be strengthened by adding specificity to them.

A guarantee is good. A guarantee that details exactly what you’re guaranteeing and what customers get back if they’re not satisfied is much better.

The fact that your new supplement for dogs has been shown to increase their lifespan is nice. The fact that, in a peer reviewed study by the University of Michigan Veterinary School, dogs taking your supplement lived an average of 2.4 years longer than dogs that didn’t, is the proof many will need to buy your product.

A testimonial saying how wonderful you are is nice. A testimonial from a client touting the specific results they got from you (“Within 22 days of hiring you to help market my chiropractic office, I got a 22x ROI on what I paid you!”) is much more meaningful…and credible.


Sometimes the best way to provide proof isn’t to tell them, but to show them. With high rates of broadband use and cheap solutions to capture and edit video, adding video proof on your site has never been easier.

You can use it to demonstrate how your software works or give people a peak inside your membership site (see the Crazy Egg home page for an example). This makes your offering more tangible so people know exactly what they’re paying for.

You can use it to show off your product by putting a mini infomercial on your site that highlights people using your product.

If you are the product, you can put a video up on your site featuring you delivering valuable content and/or your marketing message (this strategy is pretty common in the Internet marketing niche).

Here’s another example taken from a site I referenced last month that’s running a successful AdWords campaign…

They use this video to tell the site owner’s personal story of weight loss, establish their credentials and detail exactly what you get as a member of their site. By using video they deliver this information in a more compelling way that enhances their authority in the minds of their prospects.

(Oh, and notice in the right sidebar they share that they have 240,035 members and have answered 8659 questions to add more proof to the mix.)

Using video brings things to life in a way that words can’t. And, in doing so, helps make you and your claims more (everybody now!)…credible.

More Credibility Factors?

Your prospects have all been taken for a ride by advertisers countless times. They’re looking for reasons not to believe your claims. Using the 9 Credibility Factors above will increase conversions on your website by providing the peace of mind prospects need to do business with you.

These 9 techniques, however, are just the tip of the iceberg. In the comment section below, please share your favorite strategies for adding proof and credibility to a website.



Get updates on new articles, webinars and other opportunities:

Adam Kreitman

Adam Kreitman coaches business owners on how to make their websites more compelling to their prospects.. and to Google. He owns Words That Click, a firm specializing in Conversion Optimization and managing Google AdWords campaigns for small businesses.Follow him on


Comment Policy

Please join the conversation! We like long and thoughtful communication.
Abrupt comments and gibberish will not be approved. Please, only use your real name, not your business name or keywords. We rarely allow links in your comment.
Finally, please use your favorite personal social media profile for the website field.


Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. March 29, 2013 at 4:32 pm

    Glad you found it helpful, Jason! These tips are timeless, so they’ll add value to your site for as long as it’s up.

  2. Jason Vandenbrink says:
    March 29, 2013 at 4:23 pm

    This was a really great site. This is exactly what I was looking for to make my site better, and improve overall sales. Thank you so much!

  3. Dev Basu says:
    May 7, 2012 at 11:18 am

    Great list Lucas! I have another strategy for you: Showcase dynamic social proof. Eg: On your landing page selling SaaS services, showcase how someone from a particular Geography just subscribed 12 minutes ago, and another person subscribed 1/2 hour ago. It showcases social proof because other users subscribed the same way the current user is being pitched to subscribe via the CTA’s on the page.

  4. Lucas Lopes says:
    May 1, 2012 at 12:29 pm

    Fantastic post Adam. I would add another estrategy: scarcity. When you go to an e-commerce store and you see there’s only a couple items left, or when you are considering participating in an event that has only a dozen seats left, that will create some pressure for you to buy right away.

    • Russ Henneberry says:
      May 3, 2012 at 10:19 am

      Couldn’t agree more Lucas. Scarcity is a powerful motivator as long as it isn’t manufactured and fake. We have a post that details scarcity coming up — stay tuned and thanks for the insightful comment.

Show Me My Heatmap

I love sites with - combine that with and it gives such a great set of data to inform /

Andrew Martin


What makes people leave your website?